Comparison 9 min read Updated 2026-02-01

New Construction vs Renovation 2026

Build new or renovate existing? Cost comparison and decision framework.

Cost Comparison

New Construction

  • Cost per sq ft: $150-$400+
  • Timeline: 6-12 months
  • Full customization
  • Modern codes/efficiency

Major Renovation

  • Cost per sq ft: $100-$300
  • Timeline: 2-6 months
  • Work with existing structure
  • May uncover hidden issues

When to Choose

Build new when:
  • Total reno would exceed 50% of rebuild cost
  • Structure has major issues
  • Want completely different layout
  • Need to meet modern codes
Renovate when:
  • Love the location/neighborhood
  • Historic character worth preserving
  • Good bones, cosmetic updates needed
  • Budget under $150/sq ft

Related Guides